Key insights:
- Balance transfer credit cards and personal loans can both consolidate debt into 1 payment, but the better option for you depends on your payoff timeline, budget, and financial goals
- A balance transfer credit card may help you save on interest if you can repay the transferred balance during the low introductory APR period, though fees and a higher regular APR may reduce those savings
- A personal loan offers fixed rates, fixed monthly payments, and set repayment terms, which can help to make budgeting easier and provide more predictability
- Before choosing either option, borrowers should compare interest rates, fees, credit score requirements and total repayment costs to see which approach meets your needs best
When it comes to consolidating debt, 2 popular options stand out: balance transfer credit cards and personal loans. Both can help simplify your financial situation by rolling multiple debts into a single monthly payment and potentially save you money on interest. However, the right choice for you depends on your financial circumstances and goals.
Let’s explore the differences between a balance transfer and a personal loan to help you make an informed decision.
What is a balance transfer credit card?
A balance transfer credit card allows you to transfer existing debt to a new card. For example, you may transfer multiple balances as long as you don’t exceed your balance transfer limit.
Balance transfer credit cards often come with a low introductory APR on balance transfers, which lasts for a limited time, usually between 12 and 21 months. This can be an effective way to manage debt if you can pay off what you owe before the introductory APR expires. After the offer period ends, you’ll start being charged the regular APR on any remaining balance.
Balance transfer credit card pros and cons
Understanding the pros and cons of balance transfer credit cards can help you decide if they make sense for your financial situation.
Pros of balance transfer credit cards
- Save on interest: Balance transfer credit cards may offer a low introductory APR. You can avoid higher interest charges if you pay off your balance transfer during this offer period.
- Fewer monthly payments: Instead of managing multiple balances from different lenders, you can consolidate some or all of your debt onto 1 balance transfer credit card. This can help to simplify your finances and make it easier to keep track of payments.
- Flexible repayment: As long as you make the minimum payments by the due date each month, you’ll avoid higher interest charges on the transferred balance during the low introductory APR period. This can help to give you flexibility to pay more in some months and less in others during the intro period.
Cons of balance transfer credit cards
- Balance transfer fees: Most balance transfers aren’t free. For each balance transfer, credit card issuers may charge either a flat fee or a percentage of the balance (usually whichever is higher).
- Credit score requirements: Credit cards with low introductory APR offers typically require good-to-excellent credit scores. If you have a lot of credit card debt, you may have a high credit utilization ratio, which can lower your credit score. In that case, you may have a harder time getting approved.
- Introductory APRs are temporary: Depending on the credit card, your promotional period may last anywhere from 12 to 21 months. If that’s not long enough to pay off your debt, the leftover balance will be subject to the credit card’s regular, higher APR.
When may a balance transfer credit card make sense?
Balance transfer credit cards may make sense when:
- You can repay all or most of the balance during the low introductory APR period: Doing so can mean significant interest savings. If you’re confident you can repay the balance before the intro APR period ends, a balance transfer credit card could be the right move.
- You expect to save money: There may be times when a balance transfer credit card's regular APR is lower than the APRs on your existing debt, helping to make it a more economical option even if you can’t repay your full balance before the offer period ends. You’ll need to run the numbers to see if you can still save, factoring in the balance transfer fee and interest charges.
What is a personal loan for debt consolidation?
A personal loan is usually an unsecured installment loan with a fixed interest rate. An unsecured loan doesn’t require collateral. Instead, your credit score, income and other factors, such as your loan amount, determine your borrowing limit and interest rate.
You can use a personal loan for almost anything, including debt consolidation. For instance, you can use funds to repay existing credit card balances and loans. Personal loans used this way may also be called debt consolidation loans.
Typically, personal loan funds are deposited directly into your bank account. In the case of debt consolidation loans, however, some lenders may offer you the option to pay your creditors on your behalf.
Personal loan pros and cons
Like balance transfer credit cards, personal loans for debt consolidation come with their own pros and cons.
Pros of personal loans
- One monthly payment: Consolidating debt with a personal loan can mean rolling multiple debts into a single fixed monthly payment, helping to simplify your finances and make it easier to track what you owe.
- You may be able to save on interest: Depending on the loan term and interest rate you qualify for, you may save money on interest and potentially even pay your debt off sooner (particularly if there’s no pre-payment penalty).
- Fixed interest rate and monthly payments: Your interest rate typically remains the same for the life of the loan. That means you’ll know exactly what your monthly payment will be, which helps make it easier to plan and budget.
- Flexible loan terms: Personal loans may offer a wide range of terms to choose from. A longer term can allow for a lower monthly payment but may mean paying more interest over time. Meanwhile, a shorter term may result in a higher monthly payment but can mean you pay less interest overall. Either way, as long as you make your payments on time, you’ll know the exact date you’re scheduled to pay off your loan.
Cons of personal loans
- Credit score requirements: Personal loans typically require higher credit scores if you want to access the lowest APRs and save the most money. Keep in mind that lenders may also consider factors such as your debt-to-income ratio (the percentage of your gross monthly income that goes toward debt payments), income and your credit history.
- Potential fees: Some lenders may charge additional fees, such as an origination fee for processing your application and disbursing funds, or a prepayment penalty for paying off the loan early. Origination fees are typically deducted from your loan disbursement.
- You could pay more over time: If you opt for a longer loan term, you may end up paying more interest, even if the interest rate is lower than what you’re currently paying. Personal loan APRs can also range widely, with some that are comparable to credit cards.
When can a personal loan make sense?
Here are some situations when a personal loan can make sense:
- You’ll save money: If you qualify for an interest rate that’s lower than what you’re paying on your current debts, consolidating debt with a personal loan may make sense. When doing the math, consider the interest rate, loan term and any fees to figure out whether you’ll be saving money over the life of the loan.
- You can keep up with the payments: If the monthly payments are comfortably within your budget, a personal loan may be the right move. It’s not a good idea to take out a loan if you think you’ll have trouble making the payments.
- You need a longer repayment term: Many lenders let you choose a loan term, which can span multiple years. For example, Citi® Personal Loan terms can extend up to 60 months. A longer term can lower your monthly payment and give you more time to pay off debt than a balance transfer credit card.
- You prefer the predictability of fixed monthly payments: With fixed interest and a fixed term, your personal loan payments will be the same every month. You may also be able to automate your payments to help ensure you never miss a due date.
Balance transfer credit card or personal loan: which is right for you?
Your financial situation and goals will be the key factors when considering a balance-transfer credit card or a personal loan.
For example, if you need flexible payment options and can pay off your balance relatively quickly, a balance transfer credit card may be a better option. Conversely, if you prefer the stability of fixed monthly payments and need a longer repayment term to help control your monthly costs, a personal loan might be the way to go.
Citi offers flexible personal loans to qualified applicants. Rates include a 0.5% discount if you enroll in automatic payments at loan origination, and existing Citi customers may be eligible for up to $50,000.
Explore Citi Personal Loans to learn more and check your rate. No matter which option you choose, having a solid plan in place can help you pay off your debt and manage your finances going forward.
This article is for educational purposes. It is not intended to provide legal, investment, or financial advice and is not a substitute for professional advice. It does not indicate the availability of any Citi product or service. For advice about your specific circumstances, you should consult a qualified professional.